Bilawal Bhutto opposes referendum, warns of 'uncontrollable' situation on new provinces

34 mins ago

Bilawal Bhutto opposes referendum, warns of 'uncontrollable' situation on new provinces

He warned that if coercion was used, not a single PPP worker would take up arms, but the situation could nevertheless spiral beyond his control.
Bilawal Bhutto opposes referendum, warns of 'uncontrollable' situation on new provinces

Web Desk

|

18 Nov 2026

Referring to his 'bloodshed' remark, Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said that he was speaking in a specific context and that the regional situation, economic challenges, and the country's current circumstances are evident to everyone.

"This is not an ordinary economic crisis but an economic catastrophe. The public is facing serious difficulties," Bilawal said during an exclusive interview with a private TV.

"If decisions are imposed through force, I fear the situation could develop exactly as I have described," said Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari.

He warned that if coercion was used, not a single PPP worker would take up arms, but the situation could nevertheless spiral beyond his control.

"The situation will escalate to such an extent that even Mohsin Naqvi will come rushing to me, asking me to help bring things under control, saying that matters have become extremely difficult," Bilawal said.

He stressed that the public should always be told the truth, expressing concern that economic difficulties could worsen further. He said all stakeholders in the country should focus on providing economic relief to the people.

Bilawal clarified that he had not initiated the debate on a possible system collapse but had made his remarks in a particular context. He said Senator Mohsin Naqvi, who represents all of them in the Senate, had initiated the discussion on a system reset.

He explained that his comments were intended to address the circumstances that led to the debate about a system collapse.

"If someone initiates a debate, they should have the courage to listen to other opinions as well," Bilawal said, questioning whether Mohsin Naqvi alone had the right to discuss a system reset.

He maintained that he also had the right to express his views and advocate a democratic reset. He added that any effort to improve the country must focus on restoring public confidence in state institutions.

Bilawal said he had proposals on how public trust in institutions could be strengthened.

Debate over new provinces and referendum

Bilawal said the proposal to create new provinces through a referendum had become part of the ongoing political debate.

He expressed concern that despite being a major stakeholder, he had not been consulted on the matter.

He clarified that no discussion about new provinces took place during the meeting between President Asif Ali Zardari and Mohsin Naqvi. The Presidency had also issued a clarification stating that the matter was not discussed during the meeting.

Bilawal said his meeting with the prime minister was intended to improve coordination with the federal government.

He added that he had spoken to President Asif Ali Zardari following his press conference the previous day and would hold a detailed discussion with him when he visited Islamabad.

Clarifying the nature of his recent appearance, Bilawal said the event at the press club was a "Meet the Press" session, not a seminar. He noted that he spoke for an hour, followed by an hour-long question-and-answer session.

Bilawal described a referendum on the creation of new provinces as unconstitutional, referring to Article 239(4) of the Constitution.

He said the constitutional provisions were clear and that bypassing the Constitution to conduct a referendum would be inappropriate.

Referring to the no-confidence motion against the former prime minister, he said the move had been initiated in accordance with the constitutional procedure.

He added that subsequently invoking Article 5 as a justification for dissolving the assembly would amount to a constitutional violation.

Bilawal maintained that there was no justification for holding a referendum without following the constitutional procedures.

Electoral reforms and credibility of elections

Bilawal questioned how electoral reforms could be introduced if a referendum or fresh elections were proposed beforehand.

He said the credibility of the Election Commission of Pakistan and the electoral process had reached an unprecedented low in the country's history.

He noted that opposition parties had traditionally accused governments of electoral rigging in Pakistan.

However, he said this was the first time that opposition parties, the ruling party, and even coalition partners were all raising allegations of rigging.

According to Bilawal, there was widespread scepticism about whether free and fair elections could be held under the existing system.

He questioned how a referendum conducted under the same system could accurately reflect the genuine will of the people.

Bilawal also argued that people in Sindh could not be asked to decide whether a new province should be established in Punjab, nor could people elsewhere be asked to determine whether a new province should be created in Sindh.

He maintained that he had every right to express his opinion on the referendum proposal.

Bilawal reiterated that President Zardari's meeting in Lahore had not included any discussion about a referendum or the creation of new provinces.

He questioned what had suddenly prompted the discussion about new provinces and referendums.

Concluding his remarks, Bilawal said that non-political individuals often lacked practical understanding and that their proposals could also be impractical.

Comments

https://www.dialoguepakistan.com/en/assets/images/user-avatar-s.jpg

0 comment

Write the first comment for this!