Submit News
Dialogue Pakistan
No Result
View All Result
  • Citizen Journalism
  • News
  • Videos
  • Features
  • In Pictures
  • Lifestyle
  • Urdu
  • Citizen Journalism
  • News
  • Videos
  • Features
  • In Pictures
  • Lifestyle
  • Urdu
No Result
View All Result
Dialogue Pakistan
No Result
View All Result

Role of scientific calculations in moon-sighting

Web Desk by Web Desk
July 16, 2019
in Features
0
moon sighting
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The issue of moon-sighting (ruet-e-hilal) has been controversial between Peshawar and rest of the cities in Pakistan since its inception. Although, Peshawar vs all Pakistan had been accepted by all and sundry as a routine for the matter spread over decades, but the establishment of a new committee of experts by Science and Technology Minister Fawad Chaudhry to determine moon-sighting recently stirred debate among different circles on how much involvement should scientific tools have in religious subjects.

Earlier, the disagreement was between the Ruet-e-Hilal Committee and the Qasim Ali Khan Masjid, a 17th-century mosque in Peshawar. Now, this issue has exacerbated with Chairman Ruet-e-Hilal Committee Mufti Muneeb ur Rehman and Fawad Chaudhry at loggerheads over the use of scientific machinery to pre-decide the dates.

Mufti Muneeb is adamant on sighting moon with bare eyes, while Fawad Chaudhry believes that scientific methods could settle the confusion once and for all. The former sees Shariah in its true form, whilst the latter has a logical angle. This has put people in a bloody fix. Heads are spinning. It is feared that this variance of opinion may further divide the nation.

Fawad Chaudhry argues that how could sighting moon through old technology be halal and with latest technology be haram. However, later he softened his stance and said that the Islamic Ideology Council has to decide this issue. He said he had done his part by constituting the 10-year lunar calendar.

In an interview with a channel, Mufti Muneeb had said that lunar calendars were no new invention and they had existed from thousands of years.

A lunar calendar is based upon the monthly cycles of the Moon’s phases and some scholars believe that it has existed for 27,000 years.

Senior TV anchor Orya Maqbool Jan said you cannot make religion subordinate to science when it was a matter of Shariah compliance.

Talking to a channel, Mufti Raghib Naeemi had said that they used science as a secondary tool only. He said the existing moon-sighting committee had religious scholars as well as scientists in it. He said the expenditures on the committee were worth it.

In a survey conducted by a local channel, people disdained the calendar formed by Fawad Chaudhry’s team.

Earlier this year Gulf News reported that the scholars of the United Arab Emirates also deliberated on revamping moon-sighting methods for Ramadan and Eid. A section of the UAE scholars believed that sighting the moon with naked eye should be the standard. Few scholars think that the astronomical calculations could be accounted for starting a new month.

Chairman of the Arab Union for Astronomy and Space Science and Chancellor of University of Sharjah Dr Humaid Majol Al Nuaimi had said that although the scientific method of calculating the new moon’s birth was accurate, even “up to the second”, but it did not mean that the moon could be seen.

“There is a big difference between the birth of the new moon and the moon sighting; we can calculate the new moon for the next 10,000 years if we want… there are even websites that can do it,” Al Nuaimi hyad said.

In May this year, the science and technology minister had formed a new committee of comprising science and technology experts from SUPARCO (Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission) and meteorological department.

The committee was tasked to prepare an Islamic calendar for the next 10 years to decide dates of Ramzan, Eid and Muharram. 

Ministry of Science n Tech Committee to resolve #moonsighting controversy constituted pic.twitter.com/LknTHNOsOe

— Ch Fawad Hussain (@fawadchaudhry) May 7, 2019

In a tweet in June, the minister had announced that Eid ul Adha would fall on August 12 while Muharram would begin on September 1.

Meanwhile, the chairman central Ruet-e-Hilal Committee had responded that the minister was ‘unaware of religious matters’.

“Fawad Chaudhry is unaware of the system. He doesn’t even know that the committee meets at Suparco. I have previously appealed to the prime minister to let speak only concerned minister on religious issues. The science and technology minister doesn’t understand the sensitivity of the issue he shouldn’t have a licence to speak on it,” he had said.

Previous Post

Lahore drowns in rain; CM Punjab on round to check ground conditions

Next Post

The Industry Needs More Films Not Eid Releases Says Shaan Shahid

Next Post
The Industry Needs More Films Not Eid Releases Says Shaan Shahid

The Industry Needs More Films Not Eid Releases Says Shaan Shahid

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

Sunny Deol is coming to Pakistan tomorrow for Kartarpur inauguration

Sunny Deol is coming to Pakistan tomorrow for Kartarpur inauguration

1 year ago
“Forever Mera”, Sanam Chaudhry got married to USA-based singer

“Forever Mera”, Sanam Chaudhry got married to USA-based singer

1 year ago

Popular News

  • Startling connection between Dananeer’s craze and ‘The Simpsons’

    Startling connection between Dananeer’s craze and ‘The Simpsons’

    189 shares
    Share 76 Tweet 47
  • Right-wing activist Shaheer Sialvi arrested

    92 shares
    Share 37 Tweet 23
  • Pakistanis lose it as Justice Qazi calls Pakistan “gutter”

    27 shares
    Share 11 Tweet 7
  • Aamir Liaquat comes under fire for disrespecting Hindu religion

    15 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4
  • Military personnel were responsible for Ehsanullah Ehsan’s escape: DG ISPR

    15 shares
    Share 6 Tweet 4

Dialogue Pakistan

Citizen Journalism is the collection, dissemination and analysis of news by the people for the people especially by the means of internet. Dialogue Pakistan is the country's first citizen journalism portal to provide Pakistanis an opportunity to get themselves heard aiming to encourage citizen journalism inculcated with ethical values.

Category

  • Audio
  • Citizen Journalism
  • Documentaries
  • Feature Videos
  • Features
  • In House Videos
  • IN PICTURES
  • Lifestyle
  • Mobile Footage
  • New Catagory
  • News
  • News Roundup
  • Pakistan Super League
  • Photo Journalism
  • Press Conferences
  • Special Feature
  • Sports
  • Videos

Quick Links

  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

Download our APP

download on android app download on apple app
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

Copyright © 2021. Dialogue Pakistan. All Rights Reserved.
Web Development & Social Media Management by Digital Otters

No Result
View All Result
  • Citizen Journalism
  • News
  • Videos
  • Features
  • In Pictures
  • Lifestyle
  • Urdu

Copyright © 2021. Dialogue Pakistan. All Rights Reserved.
Web Development & Social Media Management by Digital Otters